November 5 2004

Badger Neighbors Oppose Army’s Plan

Rural neighbors of Badger Army Ammunition Plant are objecting to the Army’s recent announcement to discontinue bottled water.  The decision, residents say, is premature and the Army should first complete necessary studies and testing. 

Dozens of residents will be petitioning for continued bottled water at the November 10 public meeting beginning at 6:30 pm at the River Arts Center in Prairie du Sac. 

“Lack of information has been a problem from the beginning,” said Lance Delaney, a spokesperson for the group.  “The Army has still not identified the source of the contamination, test methods have been unreliable, and the long-term quality of our drinking water is still unknown.”

Nearby municipalities, including the Townships of Sumpter, Prairie du Sac, and Merrimac, have voiced similar concerns about the integrity of drinking water supplies.  In recent months, all have passed resolutions supporting a permanent solution that will assure groundwater is free from any contamination from the closing military base.

“Contaminant levels are known to fluctuate with time,” added Kevin Fitzgerald, a resident of the Windings Subdivision.  “We are petitioning for quarterly testing to establish trends in water quality and to assure that concentrations of explosives and other contaminants in our drinking water do not place human health at risk.”

In late September, the Army offered new water supply wells to 2 homes in the Water’s Edge development near Gruber’s Grove Bay.  Testing by the U.S. Army detected unsafe levels of dinitrotoluene (DNT), a compound that was used in the production of gun powder and rocket fuel.  DNT can affect the blood, nervous system, liver, kidneys, and male reproductive system in both humans and animals, and is a suspected human carcinogen. 

In December 2003, explosives were first detected in drinking water wells near Badger; since then, the Army has tested nearly 100 homes for potential contamination. 


Citizens for Safe Water Around Badger

FACT SHEET

 

DNT: The Importance of Testing Groundwater and Drinking Water for All Isomers

 

Dinitrotoluene, commonly known as DNT, exists as a mixture of two or more of its six isomers (forms).  The 2,4- and 2,6- DNT isomers are the most predominant and have been used in military munitions and dye manufacture. 

Technical grade DNT is a mixture composed of approximately 76% 2,4-DNT, 19% 2,6-DNT, and 5% other DNT isomers (3,4-DNT, 2,3-DNT, 2,5-DNT, and 3,5 DNT).  In groundwater and drinking water, however, these isomers can be found independently and in different ratios. 

If you live near a facility that has DNT contamination, it is important that your groundwater and drinking water well be tested for all known isomers of DNT. 

In certain groundwater monitoring wells inside Wisconsin’s Badger Army Ammunition Plant, for example, levels of 2,4 and 2,6-DNT are much lower than 3,4-DNT concentrations in the same well.  In one sample, 2,4- and 2,6-DNT levels were both below 0.08 parts per billion while 3,4-DNT was detected at levels 80 times higher: 6.45 parts per billion (June 2004). 

It is also possible to see one isomer of DNT in a well and not see any others.  This can come about in several different ways:  

One way is if degradation is nearly complete for other isomers and a more resistant isomer could remain.  Unlike 2,4- and 2,6-DNT, for example, 2,3-DNT has not been demonstrated to biodegradable.        

A second way, although less likely, is if there are differences in the affinity of different DNT isomers to the aquifer material and one could show up faster or slower than the other. 

Another way one isomer could show up by itself may be that the source area for the well is primarily contaminated with one isomer. 

And finally, it is possible that one or more conditions could occur at the same time, resulting in the presence of a single isomer in a specific well.

To date, residents living near Badger Army Ammunition Plant have received test results for only 2 or 3 of the 6 known DNT isomers. 

Wisconsin’s safe drinking water standard for both 2,4- and 2,6-DNT is 0.05 parts per billion.  DNT can affect the blood, nervous system, liver, kidneys, and male reproductive system in both humans and animals, and is a suspected human carcinogen.  It is anticipated that the health risks of other DNT isomers are similar due to their structural similarity.  Several recent studies, however, indicate that 3,4-DNT may be more toxic than the other more common isomers.

SOURCES: USEPA Office of Water, 2,4 and 2,6 Dinitrotoluene Health Advisory, April 1992.  Dr. Jerry Eykholt, environmental engineer and technical consultant for the Badger Restoration Advisory Board, November 6, 2004 correspondence.  J. Spain and S. Nishino, Bioremediation of DNT, Air Force Research Laboratory, Tyndall AFB, Florida,, February 2001.

Groundwater Monitoring Well Results: June 2004

The following are provided as examples.  All results are reported in parts per billion (ppb).  DBM- and ELM- series wells are located in the northeast corner of Badger Army Ammunition Plant near the Deterrent Burning Grounds.  PBN-series wells are located in the southwest portion of Badger near the Propellant Burning Grounds.

Well: DBM 8201    

2,6-DNT                        0.086

2,4-DNT                        0.042

2,3-DNT                        1.57

3,4-DNT                        6.45

Well: DBM 8202

2,6-DNT                        0.058

2,4-DNT                        0.015

2,3-DNT                        1.03

3,4-DNT                        3.80

Well: PBN 8904B

2,6-DNT                        0.159

2,4-DNT                        0.032

2,3-DNT                        0.649

3,4-DNT                        0.200

Well: PBN 8202A

2,6-DNT                        10.5

2,4-DNT                          2.7

2,3-DNT                       165.

3,4-DNT                       191.

Well: ELM 9501

2,6-DNT                        0.016

2,4-DNT                        not detected

2,3-DNT                        0.007

3,4-DNT                        0.031

 Well: PBN 8904B (duplicate)

2,6-DNT                        0.185

2,4-DNT                        0.038

2,3-DNT                        0.763

3,4-DNT                        0.239

Citizens for Safe Water Around Badger (CSWAB) is working to mobilize and empower rural communities near Wisconsin’s Badger Army Ammunition Plant in support of a sustainable future that will protect and restore the integrity of soil, water, air, and biological diversity.   For more information contact: CSWAB, E12629 Weigand’s Bay South, Merrimac, WI  53561 (608) 643-3124 or http://www.cswab.org

Citizens for Safe Water Around Badger
E12629 Weigand’s Bay South
Merrimac, WI  53561
(608) 643-3124 phone
(608) 643-0005 fax
info@cswab.org
www.cswab.org
 

Designed by DataScouts  for EarthWINS and Hosted by merr.com